Humane Wayne Muddies the Airwaves
I dont think anyone can reasonably claim that our work is moving in the direction of eliminating animal agriculture, Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) president Wayne Pacelle insisted this morning during an interview with the farm-belt AgriTalk radio program. Sure. While were at it, were happy to let you know that the government wont raise your taxes. That stain on your tie? Itll come out. And veggie burgers taste just like chicken. Humane Wayne, as he is known on Capitol Hill, provided a masterful, if typical, on-air defense of Americas richest animal rights group, refusing to concede that
well, that it is an animal rights group. - Are you trying to get people to stop eating meat? We have to drop the paranoia
We do think there are issues with the current state of production and the per capita consumption of animal products.
- Is promoting veganism a big part of your agenda? The most I ever talk about veganism is when Im talking to the ag community, or the hunting lobby, or someone whos trying to poke a hole in our work
We support Certified Humane programs.
- Can I find meat in the HSUS cafeteria? We dont have a cafeteria. People bring their own lunch or they go out.
Not surprisingly, much of the discussion centered on Ohio, a state where HSUS has threatened to sponsor a 2010 ballot initiative (similar to its California Proposition 2 effort in 2008) that would outlaw several common livestock handling practices. - Do you have plans now for Ohio, or for a ballot initiative in any other state in the near future? Were committed to stopping the intensive confinement of animals: veal crates and gestation crates and battery cages. And well continue to work on that on all fronts. And Ohio is still very much at top of mind for us, despite this effort.
The Ohio effort that Pacelle refers to is a legislative maneuver that will ask voters to decide this year whether to create a new Livestock Care Standards Board. That idea is supported by both houses of Ohios legislature and the states Governor. It would let farmers guarantee the humane handling of their animals. Not HSUS. Humane Wayne is having none of it. Were very much willing to compromise, he insists. To a point. Complaining about his carpetbaggers being pre-empted by Ohioans, Pacelle sniped: We could have sat down and, you know, negotiated that. We could have had some more terms and some more balance. We prefer not to resort to initiatives. Theyre costly, theyre divisive, and we always prefer another route
Obviously you know about Prop 2, and it would be in our interest to achieve the same set of reforms that California voters and Arizona voters approved, but were willing to talk to you before we go down that road. Here Pacelle touches on whats in our interest. Was this a slip of the tongue? We thought he was looking out for the animals best interests. Silly us. A few moments of candor were bound to slip out over the course of an hour. Here are two worth noting. - But it has to go to the voters and they have to approve it. Isnt that the same thing you did in California? Well, thats true. But again, its designed to prevent this initiative from taking effect. Its clearly a blocking maneuver.
- Do you spend money on animal welfare research
on what is the best way to care for animals? Yes, but we work on all issues related to human-animal relationships, whether its companion animals or horses or animals used in laboratories, or animals in agriculture or other settings. Were not a research-oriented organization. We dont fund research. We dont fund every local humane society.
True again. As weve been saying, HSUS funds comparatively very few of them. According to its own 2007 tax filings, the group contributed just 3.64 percent of its budget to organizations that operate hands-on dog and cat shelters. - A lot of people want to know why isnt more of that money used on actual shelters, and adoption of animals. Why isnt more of your money going to those types of programs? There are 10 billion animals raised for food in this country, and there are 7-8 million who go into shelters. We put a lot of energy on that, and we are working aggressively to address that problem
I know some of your listeners would love for us to just give all our money to shelters so they can kind of have a free-running field to do whatever they want with animals in agriculture.
- What percent of your budget would you say goes to animal shelters? Well, it depends on how you define animal shelters
If people want us to spend all of our hard dollars on animal shelters, they can support their local society. We think thats fabulous
But we have other issues we want to work on.
Before signing off, AgriTalk host Mike Adams dared to jump into one of the most embarrassing episodes in HSUSs recent history. If you find a problem, Adams asked Pacelle, some animal welfare violation or something going wrong, do you immediately put the word out about that? Or is there a lag time there?
If you know about things that are wrong, why dont you say that right now? Adams was talking about the Hallmark-Westland case, where animal cruelty clearly existed. HSUS sat on its video evidence for months while it continued. - Did you go straight to them [the USDA] as soon as you found out? No, we didnt. We went to the local prosecutor in San Bernardino County and they wanted to investigate. And they asked us to keep the information quiet while they continued their investigation.
Pacelle is displaying a lack of familiarity with the truth here. Or maybe his brain has shrunk from his vegan diet, and hes just forgotten. Either way, the San Bernardino DAs office remembered it quite differently last year. (We even called for a perjury investigation into the sworn testimony of HSUS Dr. Michael Greger.) Tune in to AgriTalk radio on Wednesday at 11:00am EDT to hear farmersreal farmersgive Pacelle a piece of their minds. And call 1-888-247-4825 during the show to add your own two cents.
Breaking News
Here's a sampling of other stories that have caught our interest today. To see a one-week archive of these items, click here.
 | | 
|
